A blue graphic with the text: The Mindset Schools Trademark Journey: Overcoming Challenges with Indie Law and The MINDSET School in different fonts, with abstract shapes in light blue, white, and lavender.
April 9, 2025

Case Study: The Mindset School – Navigating Trademark Risks for a Faith-Based Coaching Brand

In October 2022, Peggy Easterling founded The Mindset School under PDE Online Solutions, LLC. Dedicated to empowering resilient Christian women, the organization offers life coaching and online educational resources aimed at overcoming mindset limitations. Their services include one-on-one coaching, membership courses, and a community platform focused on aligning thoughts with Christian scripture. To protect her brand, Peggy sought to register “The Mindset School” as a trademark and considered forming a separate LLC for its ownership. She turned to Indie Law for expert guidance through this complex process.

Challenges: Navigating the Trademark Process

1. Extensive Search Results Causing Delays:
The initial trademark search yielded an unusually high number of results, leading to delays in providing the search results letter. This complexity required careful analysis to assess potential conflicts with existing trademarks.

2. Potential Conflicts Identified:
The search results highlighted concerns about similarities with existing trademarks, raising the possibility of registration refusal by the USPTO.

3. Risk of Cease and Desist Letters:
There was a risk that owners of similar trademarks might issue cease and desist letters, potentially leading to legal disputes or the need for rebranding.

4. Client Disappointment and Decision-Making Uncertainty:
Peggy expressed disappointment upon learning about the potential conflicts and sought clarification on the associated risks. She considered exploring alternative brand names before ultimately deciding to proceed with “The Mindset School.”

5. Lengthy Trademark Application Process:
The trademark application process is inherently time-consuming, often taking between 9 to 15 months, requiring patience and careful planning.

Solutions: Indie Law’s Strategic Approach

✔ Proactive Communication and Realistic Timelines:
Indie Law maintained transparent communication with Peggy, explaining delays and setting accurate expectations for each stage of the process.

✔ Thorough Analysis of Search Results:
Despite the high volume of search results, Indie Law dedicated additional time to conduct a comprehensive analysis, ensuring all potential conflicts were meticulously evaluated.

✔ Detailed Risk Assessment and Legal Strategy:
Indie Law provided Peggy with an in-depth search results letter, outlining identified concerns and discussing potential strategies to address them.

✔ Clarification of Risks and Service Coverage:
The team explained the risks associated with proceeding, including the possibility of receiving cease and desist letters, and clarified the scope of services included in Peggy’s package.

✔ Support in Decision-Making:
Indie Law offered resources such as naming masterclasses and quizzes to assist Peggy in exploring alternative brand names, empowering her to make an informed decision.

✔ Ongoing Education and Clarification:
The team took the time to answer Peggy’s questions, ensuring she understood each step of the trademark process.

✔ Client Portal and Monitoring:
Indie Law provided access to an online client portal for tracking application progress and implemented a quarterly monitoring system to detect any potentially conflicting trademarks.

Results: Achieving Trademark Success

✅ Informed Decision-Making:
With a clear understanding of the risks and strategies, Peggy confidently decided to proceed with “The Mindset School” branding.

✅ Successful Trademark Registration:
Despite initial concerns, the trademark was successfully registered, securing legal protection for the brand.

✅ Enhanced Client Satisfaction:
Indie Law’s proactive communication and thorough explanations alleviated Peggy’s concerns, leading to a positive client experience.

✅ Ongoing Brand Protection:
With the implementation of monitoring systems, Peggy’s trademark remains under vigilant protection, ensuring long-term security.

Client Testimonial

“Thank you for your patience with me as I navigate this process. I have made the final decision to move forward with The Mindset School branding. Should it not go as planned, I will have the information I need to be able to move forward or rebrand now if necessary rather than later down the road. I have prayerfully navigated this path so I don’t want to quickly move to something else just because there seems to be a roadblock. I believe that with your help and guidance we can navigate this path together and hopefully move forward with THE MINDSET SCHOOL brand. Again, I appreciate your help!”
Peggy Easterling

Key Takeaways

The Mindset School’s trademark journey underscores the importance of thorough research, strategic planning, and proactive communication in the trademark registration process. Indie Law’s comprehensive approach not only addressed potential obstacles but also empowered Peggy with the knowledge and support needed to make informed decisions, ultimately securing her brand’s legal protection.

Related Articles from Indie Law

For further insights into trademark registration and brand protection, consider exploring these articles:

Our RECENT blog

Should I Trademark My Business Name? Team GPT vs OpenAI’s ChatGPT

Team GPT, an AI platform, just announced they’re changing their name, not because they wanted to, but because OpenAI sent legal letters asking them to stop using “GPT.”    Despite having their own trademark filings, the company shared that they were advised to...

Trademark Design Dispute: Smucker vs Trader Joe’s

The J.M. Smucker Company (“Smucker”) has filed a federal lawsuit against Trader Joe’s Company (“Trader Joe’s”) in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Ohio, alleging that the grocer’s newly released frozen “Crustless Peanut Butter & Strawberry Jam...

What Does a Trademark Do for Your Business in Chicago?

A trademark in Chicago safeguards your business’s name, logo, and brand identity from competitors and copycats. It grants exclusive rights, helping your business stand out and grow confidently in Chicago’s diverse neighborhoods. The Impact of Trademarks on Chicago...

What Is the Purpose of a Trademark Attorney in Chicago?

A trademark attorney in Chicago ensures your business name, logo, or slogan is protected, uniquely yours, and legally enforceable. Indie Law helps businesses avoid brand theft, legal mistakes, and disputes by managing trademark registration from start to finish. Why...

What Does a Chicago Trademark Attorney Do for Your Business?

A Chicago trademark attorney protects your brand from copycats, legal risks, and avoidable business mistakes by professionally registering, monitoring, and enforcing your trademarks. Indie Law is trusted by hundreds of local entrepreneurs for clear, client-focused...

What Is a Trademark Lawyer Called?

If you’re a business owner, creative, or entrepreneur in Chicago, you’ve probably heard the term “trademark lawyer” thrown around when discussing brand protection. But what exactly is a trademark lawyer called, and what do they do? The answer might seem simple at...

Be Careful If You “Swipe”: Trademark Battles in Tinder v. Bumble

It seems like new dating apps are popping up all over the place these days. A common feature of these apps seems to be the ability to “swipe left” or “swipe right” with your finger over the image in order to show interest or not with the other person. Well, it turns...

Should I Use a Lawyer to File a Trademark?

The Importance of Trademark Protection Your brand is more than just a logo or name; it represents your reputation, your hard work, and your connection with customers. Whether you run a small business, an online shop, or a growing company in Chicago, protecting your...

Ready to Protect Your Brand?

Book a free consultation call with us today to get expert guidance on trademark registration and protection.

(Or at least download our Ultimate Trademark Checklist to make sure you’re covering all the bases.)

Did you know?

Without Trademarks, You Have ZERO Rights To Your Brand.

We’re talking business names, logos, slogans… even podcast titles. Lots of entrepreneurs don’t protect their trademarks until it’s too late.

So we made a short, free video to help you avoid the biggest, most dangerous mistakes that business owners make.