Blog

Our Latest Blogs

Your brand is your most important asset. Dive into Indie Law’s resources to guide you through the maze of trademark law and keep your brand safe from copycats and infringers!

Trademark Design Dispute: Smucker vs Trader Joe’s

The J.M. Smucker Company (“Smucker”) has filed a federal lawsuit against Trader Joe’s Company (“Trader Joe’s”) in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Ohio, alleging that the grocer’s newly released frozen “Crustless Peanut Butter & Strawberry Jam Sandwiches” infringe its trademark rights relating to its well-known Uncrustables brand of crustless PB&J sandwiches.


Key Allegations

Smucker’s complaint highlights several similarities between the two products, including:

  • Round, crustless sandwich shape with crimped edges that closely resembles the Uncrustables product.
  • Packaging featuring blue accents and a sandwich with a bite taken out, which Smucker argues mimics its own trade dress and visual presentation.
  • Evidence of consumer confusion, citing social-media posts in which individuals allegedly believed Trader Joe’s product was made by or affiliated with Smucker.

Smucker notes it does not object to frozen crustless sandwiches in general,  only to products that it believes adopt protectable design elements associated with Uncrustables. The company is seeking destruction of Trader Joe’s current packaging and inventory, an injunction barring further sales, disgorgement of profits, and damages.


Trade Dress & Trademark Implications

Distinctiveness & Trade Dress

Smucker’s position is that the sandwich’s shape, crimped edging, and bite-mark imagery function as distinctive trade dress that consumers associate with Uncrustables. If proven, these features may receive trademark protection independent of the brand name.

Functionality vs. Protectability

Trader Joe’s may argue that the sandwich’s shape and crimping are functional,  necessary to seal the filling,  and therefore cannot be protected as trade dress. Functionality is a common defense in product-design trademark litigation.

Likelihood of Consumer Confusion

To prevail, Smucker must show that Trader Joe’s product is likely to cause consumer confusion regarding the source or affiliation of the sandwiches. Early social-media reactions are cited in the complaint as supporting evidence.

Brand Investment & Reputation

Smucker asserts that the Uncrustables brand represents more than $1 billion in investment over two decades and generates substantial annual revenue. That level of brand recognition may help support its claim that the product design has acquired distinctiveness.


Lessons for Business Owners

Proactive Monitoring & Enforcement

Brand owners should monitor the marketplace for look-alike products and take action when necessary. Delayed enforcement can weaken future protections.

Protecting Packaging & Product Design

Companies can pursue registration for product shapes, packaging designs, and other distinctive elements,  not only brand names. Documenting and securing these rights early can provide valuable protection as a business scales.

Understanding Functionality Limits

Only non-functional design elements can qualify for trade dress protection. When developing products, companies should identify which features are purely aesthetic and capable of acting as brand identifiers.

Evidence Matters

Real-world examples of consumer confusion,  even informal ones like social-media posts,  can strengthen an enforcement effort.

Private-Label & Competitor Risk

As private-label offerings continue to grow, brand owners should be mindful of imitation risk and build clear differentiation into packaging and product design.

Evaluate Litigation Strategy

Trademark disputes can be expensive and time-consuming. Businesses should weigh the costs and benefits of enforcement, settlement, and alternative resolutions.


Final Thoughts

This lawsuit underscores the importance of protecting brand identity, product presentation, and trade dress,  especially in markets where private-label competition is increasing. For companies developing consumer packaged goods, establishing and enforcing distinctive design elements can play a key role in long-term brand protection.

*Disclaimer: This article is meant to share general information, not legal advice. Reading it doesn’t create an attorney-client relationship. If you’d like tailored help protecting your brand, our Indie Law Team is here to guide you

What Does a Trademark Do for Your Business in Chicago?

A trademark in Chicago safeguards your business’s name, logo, and brand identity from competitors and copycats. It grants exclusive rights, helping your business stand out and grow confidently in Chicago’s diverse neighborhoods.


The Impact of Trademarks on Chicago Businesses

Registering a trademark ensures your brand is protected by law, preventing others from using similar marks. This legal protection is critical in Chicago’s competitive market, from Wicker Park to the South Loop. Without a registered trademark, your brand could face costly disputes or even loss of rights.


Key Benefits of Trademark Registration

  • Exclusive Ownership: Your brand remains unique within your industry, enhancing local recognition.
  • Legal Enforcement: Trademarks allow you to take action against infringing businesses.
  • Brand Valuation: Registered trademarks add value to your company—attracting investors or potential buyers.
  • Market Expansion: Protection extends across Illinois and nationwide, simplifying growth.
  • Peace of Mind: Years of branding efforts are safeguarded, building trust in your local community.

Why Choose Indie Law in Chicago?

Indie Law is a dedicated trademark law firm serving Chicago startups, small businesses, and entrepreneurs for over a decade. With over 1,200 trademarks filed and 150-plus five-star reviews, Indie Law’s client-first approach and flat-fee transparency make it Chicago’s trusted trademark partner. All consultations are conducted remotely, allowing Indie Law to serve clients conveniently throughout Chicago.

What Makes Indie Law Unique:

  • Dedicated to trademark law, providing clear and consistent support for business owners.
  • Uses the proprietary RAD Method for fast, reliable filings.
  • Offers transparent pricing with no surprises.
  • Led by Joey Vitale, a highly experienced attorney known for strategic legal counsel.
  • Strong community involvement, including legal workshops and seminars.

Step-By-Step: How Indie Law Secures Your Trademark

  1. Schedule your free virtual consultation here
  2. Conduct a comprehensive trademark search for conflicts.
  3. Prepare and file your application with expert guidance.
  4. Monitor your application status and respond to examiner feedback.
  5. Receive ongoing support to enforce and maintain your trademark.

FAQs About Trademark Protection in Chicago

When should I register my trademark in Chicago?

  • The earlier, the better—preferably before launching your business or marketing. Early registration prevents conflicts and preserves your brand rights.

Can Indie Law help with international trademarks?

  • Yes, Indie Law offers guidance on protecting your brand across borders, leveraging both federal and international trademark systems.

What if my trademark application is denied?

  • Indie Law will file your next application at no additional cost if your first attempt is unsuccessful, including all filing fees.

How does Indie Law support startups and small businesses?

 

Indie Law offers premier trademark attorney services throughout Chicago, safeguarding business brands from Lincoln Park to downtown. Learn how Indie Law can protect your intellectual property.

To schedule your free virtual consultation, click here.

 

*This article is meant to share general information, not legal advice. Reading it doesn’t create an attorney-client relationship. If you’d like tailored help protecting your brand, our Indie Law Team is here to guide you.

What Is the Purpose of a Trademark Attorney in Chicago?

A trademark attorney in Chicago ensures your business name, logo, or slogan is protected, uniquely yours, and legally enforceable. Indie Law helps businesses avoid brand theft, legal mistakes, and disputes by managing trademark registration from start to finish.


Why Trademark Protection Matters for Chicago Businesses

With constant growth in Chicago neighborhoods like Lincoln Park, Logan Square, and the West Loop, business owners need effective legal tools to stand out and stay protected. Unregistered brands risk costly disputes and can even lose exclusive rights to their own business names.


Services That Set Indie Law Apart

Indie Law is a dedicated trademark law firm that uses the proprietary RAD Method to deliver simple, comprehensive support:

  • In-depth searches to spot conflicts and risks.
  • Legal guidance on names, logos, and slogans.
  • Precise trademark application filing with the USPTO.
  • All communication and office actions are handled by experts.
  • Flat-fee pricing with no hourly charges or hidden fees.
  • If your trademark is not approved, your next application is completed at no charge.
  • Personalized support from a responsive, high-rated team.

Meet Indie Law’s Trademark Attorney

Joey Vitale, Indie Law’s founder and lead attorney, is an award-winning trademark lawyer with more than 10 years of experience. He and his team have filed over 1,200 trademarks and received 150+ five-star reviews for their attentive, client-first approach. Clients praise Indie Law for seamless communication, flat pricing, and making legal processes clear.


How to Secure Your Trademark With Indie Law

  1. Book a free brand protection assessment.
  2. Indie Law runs a detailed trademark search for risks and conflicts.
  3. The team prepares and files your application with the USPTO.
  4. Attorneys communicate with trademark offices and handle examiner feedback.
  5. Clients receive ongoing updates and post-registration support.

FAQs About Trademark Attorneys in Chicago

How soon should my business file a trademark?

  • As early as possible, preferably before launch. Waiting increases the risk of conflict or losing rights to your name.

Does Indie Law guarantee results?

  • Yes. If your trademark is denied, Indie Law will file your next application free of charge (including the filing fee for one class).

Can Indie Law help startups and nonprofits?

  • Absolutely. Packages are tailored to Chicago businesses at every stage, including startups and nonprofits.

Is everything included in the advertised flat fee?

  • Yes. All trademark procedures, communications, and updates are part of the flat rate. Clients know the price in advance.

Are in-person and virtual consultations available?

  • Indie Law currently offers virtual consultations only, ensuring convenient and accessible service for all Chicago clients.

 

Indie Law offers premier trademark attorney services throughout Chicago, safeguarding business brands from Lincoln Park to downtown. Learn how Indie Law can protect your intellectual property.

To schedule your free virtual consultation, visit here,

 

*This article is meant to share general information, not legal advice. Reading it doesn’t create an attorney-client relationship. If you’d like tailored help protecting your brand, our Indie Law Team is here to guide you.

What Does a Chicago Trademark Attorney Do for Your Business?

A Chicago trademark attorney protects your brand from copycats, legal risks, and avoidable business mistakes by professionally registering, monitoring, and enforcing your trademarks. Indie Law is trusted by hundreds of local entrepreneurs for clear, client-focused guidance in securing business trademarks across Chicago.


Chicago’s Trademark Protection Services

Indie Law’s legal team supports clients in:

  • Conducting detailed trademark searches to reduce the risk of conflicts.
  • Preparing and filing trademark applications with the USPTO.
  • Addressing application concerns, such as Office Actions or refusals.
  • Providing ongoing monitoring and enforcement of trademarks for local businesses.
  • Serving clients throughout Chicago, with responsive service for entrepreneurs in all neighborhoods.

Indie Law: Chicago’s Trademark Law Firm

Founded by Joey Vitale in 2016, Indie Law has filed over 1,000 trademarks and maintains 150+ five-star reviews. The firm focuses exclusively on trademark law, offering flat-fee packages for business owners and creative professionals across Chicago.

Distinct advantages for Chicago businesses:

  • Flat-fee and signature trademark packages.
  • Responsive and clear communication with clients.
  • Publicly praised team, including lead attorney Joey Vitale and support staff, featured in testimonials.
  • Community engagement through educational outreach and online workshops.

How Indie Law Guides Your Brand Protection

  1. Schedule an initial consultation.
  2. Complete a comprehensive name and mark search.
  3. Get help with federal trademark registration.
  4. Access follow-up monitoring to protect your trademark.
  5. Receive fast, actionable support for infringement or enforcement issues.

Trusted by Local Entrepreneurs

Indie Law helps businesses secure and maintain trademarks, which is critical for avoiding disruption and building a lasting community reputation. Public client feedback highlights Indie Law’s proactive communication, affordable pricing, and reliable service for business owners in Chicago.


FAQs for Chicago Businesses

How long does trademark registration take in Chicago?

  • Typical registration times are 8–12 months, depending on USPTO processing.

Does Indie Law serve startups, small businesses, and nonprofits?

  • Yes, Indie Law offers tailored services for various business types, including local nonprofits and new ventures.

What sets Indie Law apart from other law firms?

  • Exclusive focus on trademarks, flat fees, and a uniquely responsive Midwest approach distinguish the team.

Are consultations in-person or online?

  • All Indie Law consultations are virtual, providing flexible access for clients throughout Chicago.

Can Indie Law assist with international trademark matters?

Indie Law offers premier trademark attorney services throughout Chicago, safeguarding business brands from Lincoln Park to downtown. Learn how Indie Law can protect your intellectual property.

To schedule your free virtual consultation, visit www.indielaw.com/call

*This article is meant to share general information, not legal advice. Reading it doesn’t create an attorney-client relationship. If you’d like tailored help protecting your brand, our Indie Law Team is here to guide you.

What Is a Trademark Lawyer Called?

If you’re a business owner, creative, or entrepreneur in Chicago, you’ve probably heard the term trademark lawyer thrown around when discussing brand protection. But what exactly is a trademark lawyer called, and what do they do?

The answer might seem simple at first, but they’re typically called trademark attorneys. But depending on their specialization and the nature of your legal needs, they might also go by other titles such as intellectual property (IP) attorney, brand protection lawyer, or trademark counsel. Each role shares a common goal: to help businesses secure, manage, and defend their brand identity.

Let’s take a closer look at what each of these titles means, how they differ, and why working with the right professional in Chicago and its surrounding areas is key to protecting your intellectual property.


Common Titles for Trademark Lawyers

Trademark law covers a wide range of services, from registering trademarks to enforcing them when someone infringes on your rights. Because the field is broad, lawyers who handle these matters often use slightly different professional titles. Here are the most common ones you’ll see:

Trademark Attorney

This is the most direct and widely used title. A trademark attorney is a licensed lawyer who focuses primarily on helping individuals and businesses register, maintain, and enforce trademarks. They are trained in federal trademark law and often have experience dealing with the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO).

Trademark attorneys can:

  • Conduct comprehensive trademark searches to ensure your mark is available.
  • File and monitor trademark applications with the USPTO.
  • Handle Office Actions or oppositions to registration.
  • Represent clients in infringement disputes.

In Chicago, where many small and growing businesses are competing for visibility, trademark attorneys play a crucial role in ensuring brands stay protected in a crowded marketplace.

Intellectual Property (IP) Lawyer

An intellectual property lawyer handles a wider range of cases beyond just trademarks. This type of attorney deals with all forms of IP, including:

  • Trademarks (logos, brand names, slogans)
  • Copyrights (creative works such as art, music, writing)
  • Patents (inventions and new processes)
  • Trade Secrets (confidential business information)

When someone in Chicago refers to their “IP attorney,” they may be talking about a professional who oversees all aspects of their intellectual property portfolio, ensuring that each element of their brand is legally safeguarded.

Trademark Counsel or IP Counsel

The term “counsel” is often used when the lawyer serves in an advisory capacity. A trademark counsel might work directly with a company or serve as an in-house advisor, helping manage and enforce trademark rights across various jurisdictions.

These professionals are common in larger corporations, but small businesses and startups in Chicago may also work with trademark counsel through law firms offering flexible legal arrangements.

Trademark Litigator

While some trademark attorneys focus on registration, others specialize in litigation, representing clients in disputes involving trademark infringement, dilution, or misuse. A trademark litigator is the professional you need when someone copies your brand name or logo and refuses to stop.

They are experienced in courtroom procedures, negotiation, and settlement, and they understand how to apply both state and federal trademark laws to achieve favorable outcomes.


Why Understanding the Title Matters

Knowing what a trademark lawyer is called isn’t just a matter of vocabulary, it can help you find the right expert for your needs. Chicago has a wide range of legal professionals offering trademark services, but their titles can signal the depth and scope of their practice.

Here’s why it matters:

  1. Specialization Saves You Time and Money
    A lawyer who focuses solely on trademarks will have the most up-to-date knowledge of USPTO regulations and filing best practices.
  2. Avoiding Costly Mistakes
    Trademark applications can be denied for minor errors or incomplete filings. A dedicated trademark attorney minimizes those risks.
  3. Full Protection for Your Brand
    A general business lawyer may not catch every potential infringement or issue with your mark, but a trademark attorney will.
  4. Strong Representation in Disputes
    Should your brand be challenged or copied, having a lawyer who understands trademark litigation can make the difference between a quick resolution and a lengthy battle.

What Trademark Lawyers Actually Do

Trademark attorneys wear many hats. Their work extends far beyond just filing paperwork. Here’s a breakdown of the core services most Chicago trademark lawyers provide:

  • Trademark Searches: Ensuring that your brand name or logo isn’t already in use before filing an application.
  • Filing Applications: Preparing and submitting trademark applications with the USPTO and handling any follow-up communication.
  • Responding to Office Actions: Addressing any issues or questions raised by the USPTO examiner.
  • Trademark Monitoring: Keeping an eye out for potential infringements or misuse of your brand.
  • Cease-and-Desist Actions: Drafting and sending formal letters to stop others from using similar marks.
  • Enforcement and Litigation: Representing you in disputes, oppositions, or court cases involving your trademark.
  • Renewals and Maintenance: Managing trademark renewals to keep your registration active.

In short, a trademark attorney helps ensure that your brand is both legally protected and strategically positioned for long-term success.


The Chicago Advantage: Local Expertise with National Reach

Choosing a Chicago-based trademark lawyer offers unique benefits. Chicago’s diverse economy, spanning industries like tech, manufacturing, retail, and design, makes it a hub for brand innovation. Local attorneys understand this environment and tailor their approach accordingly.

They’re also familiar with:

  • Illinois state trademark laws
  • Local courts and enforcement procedures
  • Regional business challenges and opportunities

Whether you’re in downtown Chicago, Oak Park, Evanston, Naperville, or another nearby area, hiring a trademark attorney who understands the local market ensures personalized and efficient service.


How to Choose the Right Trademark Attorney in Chicago

When evaluating trademark attorneys, consider these key factors:

  1. Experience and Focus – Look for attorneys who specifically focus on trademark law rather than general business law.
  2. USPTO Registration – Verify that the attorney is licensed to practice before the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office.
  3. Client Reviews – Read feedback from other business owners to gauge reliability and results.
  4. Clear Communication – Choose someone who explains the process in simple terms and keeps you informed every step of the way.
  5. Transparent Fees – Many Chicago trademark attorneys now offer flat-fee trademark services for added peace of mind.

Common Misconceptions About Trademark Lawyers

Even experienced business owners often misunderstand trademark law. Let’s clear up a few myths:

  • Myth 1: Any lawyer can file a trademark.
    Reality: While technically true, only specialized trademark attorneys understand the nuances of federal trademark law and USPTO procedures.
  • Myth 2: A trademark is automatic once you start using a name.
    Reality: You gain some protection through use, but federal registration provides the strongest legal rights.
  • Myth 3: I only need a lawyer if there’s a dispute.
    Reality: The best time to hire a trademark attorney is before you file. They help you avoid conflicts before they arise.
  • Myth 4: Trademarks only apply to large companies.
    Reality: Small businesses benefit the most from trademarks because they prevent bigger competitors from claiming your name or idea.

Bringing Your Brand to Life Starts Here

At Indie Law, we help entrepreneurs, creators, and small business owners in Chicago and beyond secure their brand identity with confidence. Our experienced trademark attorneys guide you through the entire process, from search and filing to enforcement and renewal, so you can focus on growing your business while we handle the legal details.

Located at 3033 N Clark St, Chicago, IL 60657, Indie Law is known for its approachable, client-focused service. Whether you’re launching a new product or defending an established brand, our attorneys make the process clear and stress-free.

You can reach Indie Law by calling +1 312-766-6889 or emailing hello@indielaw.com. We’re here to make trademark protection simple, affordable, and effective. Contact us today!


Why Indie Law Is the Trusted Choice for Chicago Businesses

What sets Indie Law apart is its dedication to creative entrepreneurs and small business owners. The firm believes that protecting your brand shouldn’t be complicated or intimidating. Their attorneys break down complex legal concepts into actionable steps, providing personalized attention to every client.

From the first consultation to the final registration certificate, Indie Law ensures your trademark journey is handled with care and precision.

So, what is a trademark lawyer called?
They might be referred to as a trademark attorney, IP lawyer, trademark counsel, or brand protection attorney, but the goal is always the same: to protect your business’s most valuable asset, your brand identity.

For Chicago entrepreneurs, having the right legal partner can make all the difference. Whether you’re naming a new product, protecting a logo, or enforcing your rights against infringement, a trademark attorney ensures your brand stands strong in a competitive market.

If you’re ready to take that next step in protecting your business, contact Indie Law at +1 312-766-6889 or send an email to hello@indielaw.com.
Your brand deserves the best protection, and with Indie Law, you’ll get exactly that.

Trademark Showdown: What the Death Wish vs. Liquid Death Case Teaches Entrepreneurs

Death Wish Coffee has filed a federal lawsuit against Liquid Death, accusing the canned water brand of trademark infringement.

The conflict stems from Liquid Death’s trademark applications for coffee-related names like “Liquid Death” and “Deathuccino.” Death Wish, known for its high-caffeine coffee and skull-themed branding, claims the move could confuse consumers and dilute its well-established identity.

The lawsuit, filed in California, alleges that both companies’ use of dark, edgy visuals and the shared “Death” theme could lead to consumer confusion, especially if Liquid Death launches coffee drinks.

Death Wish also raised concerns about reverse confusion, where consumers might think its products are from, or affiliated with, the more well-known Liquid Death brand. Attempts to resolve the issue privately reportedly failed.

Liquid Death responded publicly, stating it has no immediate plans to launch coffee but maintains that no brand can monopolize the word “Death.”

This case is a timely reminder for businesses: distinct branding and proactive legal protection are crucial in competitive markets.


Branding Trademark: Why It Matters

First‑impression and shelf‑impact

  • How packaging, naming, visual style affect how customers perceive your brand.
  • In this case: Two brands with similar “DEATH” root, edgy look, could lead to confusion.

The business/moral asset of brand identity

  • A strong, distinctive brand builds customer loyalty, premium pricing, and defensibility.
  • Why a brand isn’t just a name – it’s trust, recognition, and unique positioning.
  • A brand’s identity (name, look, feel, voice) can become a legal asset (trademark).
  • When another business encroaches on that identity (name/appearance/market), there is risk of confusion, dilution, loss of uniqueness.
  • The case demonstrates how even when two companies are in different product categories (water vs coffee), expansion by one into the other’s category can trigger conflict.

Key Lessons for Entrepreneurs & Creators

Choose a distinctive brand early

  • Avoid names/themes that are overly common, generic, or similar to others in your category.
  • Your brand should stand out and minimize risk of confusion.

Think about future product expansion

  • Even if you’re in one niche now, your brand might expand – so ensure the name works broadly.
  • Case: a water brand wanting to move into coffee triggered the dispute.

Monitor the market and your category

  • Keep an eye on what other brands are doing, especially those that share similar branding elements.
  • As your brand grows, you’ll want to protect it.
  • Register your trademarks, monitor for infringement, and enforce when necessary.
  • Legal protection isn’t optional if your brand becomes important.

Communicate your brand’s value internally and externally

  • Your team and your market should clearly understand what your brand stands for. That clarity helps you avoid misalignment and brand dilution.
  • For service providers (coaches, designers, marketing pros), branding is as important as your core offering.

*This article is meant to share general information, not legal advice. Reading it doesn’t create an attorney-client relationship. If you’d like tailored help protecting your brand, our Indie Law Team is here to guide you.

Our Latest Blog

Your brand is your most important asset. Dive into Indie Law’s resources to guide you through the maze of trademark law and keep your brand safe from copycats and infringers!

Did you know?

Without Trademarks, You Have ZERO Rights To Your Brand.

We’re talking business names, logos, slogans… even podcast titles. Lots of entrepreneurs don’t protect their trademarks until it’s too late.

So we made a short, free video to help you avoid the biggest, most dangerous mistakes that business owners make.

Wanna see it?